February 5th, 2011
Dear W Fund Members,
Regarding the final resolution of 20 Bayard Street, in the 4th quarter letter we mentioned that we'd send an update after the latest court date which occurred this week. The judge did not rule on whether to approve or deny the Debtor's plan, but said that she will finish writing her decision and read it in court on March 8th. Much of the time in court last Tuesday was spent discussing what would happen next if she denies the plan.
Based on everything we have seen in court and everything the judge has said during the last 14 months, it seems likely that the judge will deny the Debtor's plan, which is exactly the outcome we want. We have made a motion that in the event the plan is denied, the case be converted from Chapter 11 (reorganization) to Chapter 7 (liquidation). Just before the February 1 Court date the United States Trustee filed papers with the court supporting conversion to Chapter 7 in the event that a plan is not confirmed. We were happy to see that. The most important thing that happened last Tuesday is that it became clear that the US Trustee supports that approach and that the judge wanted to hear the Trustee's input on our motion to convert to Chapter 7 before finalizing her decisions on whether or not to confirm the Debtor's plan, and then, if denied, whether to convert to Chapter 7.
So hopefully on March 8th we will hear Judge Stong read her decision to deny their plan, and then grant our motion to convert to Chapter 7. If those two things happen, then a Chapter 7 Trustee would be appointed. The 37 units that serve as our collateral [the 19-story building has a total of 62 units - the other 25 were sold in 2008 at an average price point north of $800 per square foot] would be offered as a package for sale. Given the size of the deal, the excellent location and views, the improving market conditions, etc., it is quite possible that one of the many real estate investment firms scouring the market for deals may well buy it for the total amount owed to us (inclusive of all our legal fees and the court-mandated 24% default rate of interest). If, however, the bids fall short of a number that we deem to be acceptable, then we will be allowed to credit-bid the amount owed to us and take possession. Either of the these outcomes would be excellent for the fund and result in a significant gain, which would offset the lower-than-usual returns that we have been experiencing.
The wild card is that at this point, the Debtor's back is to the wall, and they know that they are out of time - they only have between now and March 8th to come up with some major enhancement to the plan that they have put forward to have any chance of confirmation. If they were to (for example, in the 11th hour) propose paying our loan down by $3 or $4 million and increasing their proposed rate from 4.5% to 8% then they would have a very good chance of having their plan confirmed (and, of course, interest would then be paid to W Financial on the current total balance owed), but in court they have claimed not to have the cash to be able to make a significant principal paydown, thus we see this outcome as unlikely.
We will report again following the March 8th court date, and meanwhile we are very busy with a good new batch of deals. If you have any questions please do not hesitate to call.
With warm regards,
Gregg, David & Marc
|