August 27, 2009
Mr. Charles Smith
P.o. Box 3333
New York, NY 11963
re: a few words on our ex-borrower, Annie Leibovitz
Dear Mr. Smith,
Recently, with various news stories breaking in publications ranging from the New York Post to this week’s New York Magazine, the tragic story of Annie Leibovitz’s disastrous approach to her finances has been playing out on a very public stage. Thus, over the last few weeks I have heard from several of our investors who recall that at some point in time we had made a loan to Annie Leibovitz, and they were wondering if we had any exposure. I have always found that what several people express, many people are thinking about so I thought I would write a brief note on this topic. The short answer is “no”.
We had “the best of Annie”, so to speak. Our loan closed on 5/28/2004 and was repaid 6/30/2005 upon the sale of her most valuable piece of collateral, her incredible 14,000 square foot studio on West 26th Street in West Chelsea. At the time we made her an $11,500,000 loan in the spring of 2004, she had pledged more than $22 million of her high-quality real estate collateral to W Financial, including three properties in West Chelsea, three in Greenwich Village, as well as her 225 acre Rhinebeck property. At that moment in time (June 2005) when she repaid our loan, Annie quite conceivably could have “saved herself” (financially speaking). Our bridge loan had solved some specific cash flow problems for her, and she had successfully sold some property and repaid the loan. That moment represented a clear fork in the road where the story could have had a happy ending, but unfortunately she chose the now-familiar path of greater and greater leverage, and, as a result, this stellar talent is now sadly (and unproductively) burdened and distracted by an “elephant in the room” that can no longer be ignored.
About a year ago W Financial was approached again and asked to consider making a new loan by Annie’s new financial advisor. We were offered a mixed bag of collateral (as described in the NY Magazine article) and asked to consider lending more than double our previous loan amount. We saw the situation for the train wreck it was soon to become, and not only declined it, (after all, the three best pieces of collateral had already been sold off in 2005), but I also did my best to dissuade the financial advisor from continuing to pursue the path of ever-greater leverage. Unfortunately they decided to double down and somehow managed to borrow $24 million. Not sure what the exit strategy was for either the lender or for Ms. Leibovitz.
At any rate, the Fund’s loan was a great success and is now part of our history, and at this point we can only wish Annie Leibovitz well as she seeks to somehow extricate herself from the spider’s web that she has spun.
Yours truly,
 |